Pros and Cons of the Bed in a Box

Now if you haven’t noticed already, we here at Time to Sleep has looked at a lot of Bed in a Boxes. In fact, that’s pretty much all we do. That doesn’t mean that I think that they’re the perfect choice for everyone. As with everything in life, there are pros and cons, and one solution does not fit all. So what can a mattress in a box offer you that the traditional mattress industry can’t, and vice versa?

Define the Bed in a Box

First of all, what is the bed in a box?

The bed in a box concept has emerged in competition to the traditional mattress shopping and delivery methods. This concept refers to a type of mattress that is compressed, rolled, and delivered in a compact box. These mattresses are typically made of foam, or they can be hybrid mattresses with a combination of foam and other materials. The compressed packaging allows for convenient shipping and easy moving around, which is why some companies can even offer same day delivery within metro areas. Once unpacked, the mattress expands and regains its original shape within a few hours or days. Bed in a box mattresses have gained immense popularity due to their convenience, affordability, and variety of options available in the market, and have changed the face of furniture shopping forever.

What did the Bed in a Box Replace?

It hasn’t necessarily replaced anything specific, but it has provided an alternative to the traditional mattress buying process, offering a more convenient and streamlined experience. In the past, purchasing a mattress typically involved visiting physical stores, trying out different models, and arranging for bulky and sometimes expensive delivery. The bed in a box model eliminates the need for in-store visits and offers the convenience of compact packaging and direct-to-consumer shipping. While traditional mattress shopping still exists, the bed in a box model has provided consumers with an alternative option that has gained popularity in recent years.

What’s Good about the Bed in a Box

Bed in a box mattresses have become all the rage in recent years due to their convenience and unique features. Here are some advantages of bed in a box mattresses:

  1. Convenience: One of the biggest advantages of bed in a box mattresses is their convenience. They are compressed and rolled into a compact box, making them easy to transport and maneuver through narrow doorways or tight spaces. This eliminates the need for a bulky delivery process and allows for easy setup in any room of your choice. You’ll often find that the delivery costs and delivery service is much faster and more convenient.
  2. Easy Setup: Bed in a box mattresses are designed for easy setup. Once you unpack the mattress onto your bed frame and remove the packaging, it starts to expand and regain its original shape. Within a few hours or over a couple of days, depending on the specific mattress, it fully expands and is ready to use.
  3. Variety of Options: There are so many types of mattresses available in the market, offering various materials, firmness levels, and features. Whether you prefer a memory foam mattress, latex, hybrid, or other mattress types, you can find the perfect mattress that suits your preferences. Even just among memory foam mattresses, you have so many options. And you have access to all these choices at the tips of your fingers, without ever having to leave your home!
  4. Cost-Effective: Bed in a box mattresses often come at a more affordable price compared to traditional mattresses. By eliminating the need for middlemen and retail markups, bed in a box companies can offer competitive prices without compromising on quality. This makes them a budget-friendly option for many people.
  5. Quality and Comfort: Despite their compressed packaging, bed in a box mattresses are designed to provide high-quality comfort and support. They often incorporate advanced layers of foam or hybrid constructions that contour to your body, relieve pressure points, and promote proper spinal alignment for a good night’s sleep.
  6. Risk-Free Trials and Warranties: Many bed in a box mattress companies offer generous trial periods and warranties. This allows you to try out the mattress in the comfort of your home for an extended period (usually several months) and return it if you’re not satisfied. Additionally, most companies provide warranties that cover manufacturing defects, giving you peace of mind regarding the durability and longevity of your purchase.
  7. Improved Sleep Hygiene: Bed in a box mattresses are typically made with materials that are resistant to dust mites, allergens, and moisture. This can contribute to improved sleep hygiene, making them a good option for individuals with allergies or sensitivities.

Remember, while there are many benefits to bed in a box mattresses, it’s important to do thorough research, read reviews, and choose a reputable brand to ensure you’re getting a mattress that suits your needs and preferences.

What are the Drawbacks of Choosing a Bed in a Box?

While bed in a box mattresses offer many advantages, there are also some potential drawbacks to consider:

  1. Limited Testing Opportunity: Unlike traditional mattress shopping, where you can try out different mattresses in a mattress store, buying a bed in a box mattress means you don’t have the opportunity to test it before making a purchase. While the trial periods offered by many companies help mitigate this issue, there is still a level of uncertainty until you receive and sleep on the mattress. However, with the traditional mattress, you usually only get to trial it for 20 minutes in store as opposed to 100 night trials with the bed in a box.
  2. Variable Comfort: Comfort is subjective, and what works for one person may not work for another. While bed in a box mattresses offer a variety of options, it can be challenging to gauge the exact comfort level of a mattress without trying it first. Even with trial periods, it may take several weeks or months to determine if the mattress truly suits your preferences. That said, in most cases with the traditional mattress, once it leaves the store, there’s no going back.
  3. Initial Odor: When you first unpack a bed in a box mattress, it may emit a noticeable odor. This is known as off-gassing and is caused by the release of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from the materials used in the mattress. While the smell is typically temporary and dissipates over time, it can be unpleasant for some people.
  4. Limited Edge Support: Bed in a box mattresses, especially those made primarily of foam like the memory foam mattress, may have less edge support compared to the traditional mattress. This means that sitting or sleeping near the edges of the bed may cause a slight sinking feeling, and it may be more challenging to sit or sleep on the edge without feeling like you might roll off.
  5. Potential for Heat Retention: Some foam-based bed in a box mattresses, particularly the memory foam mattress, may have a tendency to retain body heat, leading to a warmer sleeping experience. While many manufacturers incorporate cooling technologies or breathable  mattress materials to address this issue,  you may prefer a hybrid mattress, or the traditional mattress if you’re a hot sleeper.
  6. Durability Concerns: While of course we strongly recommend you get a high-quality mattress, some lower-priced bed on a box options may have durability concerns compared to the typical mattress. The compressed packaging and shipping process can place stress on the mattress materials, potentially affecting its long-term performance. It’s crucial to research and choose a reputable brand known for producing durable mattresses. And you’re definitely going to have a very different experience if you’re buying a cheap mattress compared to a luxury mattress.
  7. Environmental Impact: The generous sleep trials that bed in a box mattress companies offer may ironically contribute to additional waste compared to traditional mattresses. The typical mattress isn’t easily returned, which reduces waste. While some companies prioritize sustainable practices, use eco-friendly materials and take care to donate returned mattresses to worthwhile causes, it’s important to consider the environmental impact of the mattress and the company’s policies.

Is the Bed in a Box Right for Me?

There’s a reason the bed in a box has taken the world by storm. However, it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons of bed in a box mattresses compared to the traditional mattress and consider your personal preferences, budget, and specific needs before making a decision. It’s also important to remember that not all bed in a box companies are the same. Some don’t offer trial periods, some charge  for shipping, some have a greater or lesser impact on the environment. Here, we do love the bed in a box and how it’s flipped the traditional mattress on its head, but it’s not for everyone. We think it’s worth giving it a good shot, especially the ones with the free trial periods. At the end of the day though, you need to find the best sleep system for your body, within your budget. 

We wish you all the best in your hunt for your perfect mattress!

Related Articles